Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Water Mill Building Supply is one of the biggest True-Values in America, providing a large range of almost every building provide you might need.
Reviews (11)
Write a Review
Jacob Owczarek
Mar 28, 2022
I was a regular customer at WMBS. I went there to order specialty faucet hoses back in around October last year (2021). To avoid any misunderstandings I brought with me the exact house I needed. Sale Rep said it will take few months to get them, which I presumed. I was charged right away full amount at that time. In February I received a phone call that my order is available for pick up, unfortunately there was a different finish that I ordered.

Sales Rep assumed I will take whatever and tried to sell me a story that the finish I wanted is no longer available. After explaining him that the manufacturer assured me they still produce them (yes I called), SR check again and of course it was available. He said it should take about 2 weeks to have them delivered. At that time I was not informed about any price changes or additional charges for different finish or anything.

Simply wait few more weeks for the right hoses to be delivered. 4 weeks later I got a call again that right items are ready for pick up and then I was charged additional 30% for different finish. Sales rep admitted that was his fault, he didn't mentioned to me in February that there will be an additional charge. He also explained that he had to cover the cost of shipping and returning the wrong item( which is not the client fault).

I am happy I finally got the right items, but I am very disappointed that I have to pay for their mistakes, because I am out of time to order somewhere else. Their location is very convenient and will give WMBS another chance but if something like this happens one more time I will take my business somewhere else.
Angel Velez
Feb 17, 2022
Needs to expand their inventory in more items they don't stock like 1/2"4"/6"/8"/10"/12"18' versateck azek composite plastic materials amoung other items. By keeping a fair commitment in material supplies can help improve your loyal customers to keep shopping at your location that can make that difference for lumberyards business! Something to think about?.
Chris Rosani
Jan 22, 2022
Always have everything we need. great service great employees
James Smyth
Feb 27, 2021
Watermill Building charged me an additional 3.5% surcharge for using a credit card. First time ever this happened to me in a store. When I inquired on it, I was told it was a NY State COVID mandated charge. This turned out not to be true when I went home and looked it up: Each store can charge if they want which no other business establishment I know of does. Sorry to see WB do this to once loyal customers like myself
Kyle McCarthy
Nov 27, 2020
Incredible range of inventory. Super service. Informed staff, they know hardware.
Brownie The Dog
Nov 13, 2020
Professional and helpful staff. Great selection of paint choices, hardware and high end plumbing fixtures. Came here after visiting Blackman's which was a total disaster. Was pleasantly surprised by knowledgeable and helpful staff at the WaterMill building supply showroom. Selection of products was amazing too. Will definitely be coming back. Highly recommend.
Hansel
Dec 06, 2019
It's sad but I always feel judged / they think I'm going to steal something from them. I'm a minority that happens to own a house in Bridgehampton South. I travel the world extensively and this is just one of those places. People are not nice / have something stuck up their *****.
Armando Siciliani
Jan 21, 2019
Very helpful people I've been working over there doing electrical work! Always helping customer's!
Vitali Sajkowski
Jun 06, 2018
Great Store. Great knowledgeable and helpful associates work there.
Riki J.
Sep 03, 2017
Phenomenal staff, management and ownership. From the top to the bottom the service is second to none. Benjamin Moore paint is second to none and the staff in the paint department can point you in the right direction if your having difficulty making a choice and always match the color you need perfectly.
Kotaro Okumura
Feb 24, 2016
They carry a large assortment of products, very useful as there are no other hardware stores in Watermill!